top of page

Caring for our customers in times of uncertainty

Since our humble beginnings in 1874, Wyandot Mutual Insurance Co. has been striving to provide fair and adequate coverage to all Ohio residents, from farm communities to large cities. Our trusted agents live in the communities they serve, so you can be sure you'll receive personalized attention. Our service is backed by over a century of knowledge and experience, and a dedication to the continual improvement of our products and technology. We take pride in our first-class claims service and do our best to get you back on your feet as soon as possible in your time of need. If you're looking for a local company to serve your Home, Farm & Rental Insurance needs, contact one of our trusted agents for a quote.

Find us at:
150 Highland Parkway
Upper Sandusky OH 43351

Hours:
Monday -Friday
8:00 AM - 4: PM
 
Tel:
(419)-294-2862

Fax :
419-294-5263
 

Board of Directors

STAFF

TITLE

David Karcher 

Dennis Lenhart

Rick McCullough

Bruce Kuenzli

Vicki Orians

Patrick Potts

Chairman
Vice Chairman
Director

Director
Director
Director
Served since 1995
Served since 1987
Served since 1992
Served since 2016
Served since 2017
Served since 2019

eMPLOYEES

Wendie Stillberger

Alishia Beagle 

Brad Kagel 

Chad Kidd

Erin Rall

Nick Graymire 

Tara Thiel    

Jake Kiene

Nathan Weaver

Cody Brown

President
Secretary/Treasurer
Claims Manager
Claims Representative
Claims Administrator
Marketing Manager
Underwriter
Inspection Manager/IT
Inspector
Inspector

Served since 2010
Served since 2009
Served since 2013
Served since 2023
Served since 2023

Served since 2018
Served since 2001
Served since 2014
Served since 2015
Served since 2022
bottom of page